Manors
plans have its mobile home tenants
worrying
Mail Tribune / Bob
Pennell
Helen
Schaffran has lived in the Crest
Imperial Mobile Estates park for 26
years and has no plans to move. She
says she isnt going to let the
Rogue Valley Manor, her landlord,
force her to move when the Manor
makes way for a new hotel on the land
where her single-wide sits.
Helen Schaffran had no
plans to pack up and move.
More than a
quarter-century ago, she and her
husband, Al, settled into the quiet
mobile home park on Ellendale Drive
and decided to make it their home.
When her husband died
two years ago, Schaffran stayed put.
She said shed never abandon the
memories living inside the
26-year-old single-wide.
But for Schaffran and
the 50 families living in Crest
Imperial Mobile Estates, packing day
is coming.
A hotel will one day
stand where their homes sit.
Residents at Crest
Imperial and two threatened
courts in Ashland have found
themselves in a predicament that
makes clear the dilemma mobile home
dwellers face when a park owner
decides to sell or convert the land.
The Pines Mobile Home
Park and the Lower Pines park in
Ashland appear to be safe for now
plans to build a bank at one
site have been withdrawn and an
Ashland landlord purchased the other
park, promising to preserve it as
affordable housing. But Lower
Pines owner just announced a 67
percent hike in residents rent.
The big question for
Crest Imperial residents where
will we go? is complicated by
tight wallets, a limited supply of
affordable housing and local zoning
policies that make it nearly
impossible to move a mobile home.
Worried the parks
pending closure is a sign of things
to come, residents and others say
its time to think about ways to
protect mobile home owners and
preserve a type of housing that meets
the needs of families living on low
and fixed incomes.
Losing more than a home
Ceramic pigs and frogs
perch on shelves and lounge on table
tops, dozens of magnets stick to the
goldenrod refrigerator and boxes of
bowling trophies sit in a spare
bedroom in Schaffrans home.
"Forty years of
gathering and they want to take it
all away," she said, her
frustration made clear by the scowl
fixed to her face. "Thats
what is hurting."
At 67, Schaffran said
shes scared to think what will
happen when the Rogue Valley Manor
moves ahead with its plan to turn the
Crest Imperial site into a hotel and
conference center.
The Manor, which won the
citys approval for the project
in February, is required by Oregon
law to give park residents a
years notice before it plans to
close the court or pay moving costs
up to $3,500 per home owner. Manor
representatives say they have no
definite timeline for construction of
the hotel.
"The residents are
obviously concerned about their
future, and we are, too," said
Brian McLemore, executive vice
president of development for Pacific
Retirement Services, the Manors
parent company. "But we think
its premature to give notice to
residents when we have no immediate
plans to develop."
It could be 10 to 20
years before the Manor moves ahead
with a project as complicated as a
hotel and conference center, McLemore
added.
"Until we have a
plan to develop the property, we
dont have a plan to address the
relocation issues," he said.
"For us to put together that
plan ... is just a waste of time at
this point."
The Manor has encouraged
Schaffran and other Crest Imperial
residents to apply for its low-income
and senior housing, but Schaffran and
her neighbors resist the idea of
moving into subsidized apartments.
"You have to give
up your laundry, you have to give up
your deep freeze ... you have to give
up a lot," Schaffran said.
"I dont want low-income
housing. I want my home."
Though Schaffran owns
her mobile outright, she said
shes in the same spot as many
of the families who reside in older
units.
Living in homes built in
the 1970s and 80s, a number of
Crest Imperial families are paying
mortgages on something they
cant move or sell.
They stand to lose more
than their homes. They may be out
thousands of dollars.
"It just plain old
hurts"
Residents in Crest
Imperial estimate that as many as 80
percent of their neighbors are
elderly, disabled or both. They live
on fixed incomes. Some say
theyre forced at times to
decide between buying food or heating
their homes.
Park resident Ron Heath,
who survives on $407 a month, said
hes prepared to make tough
choices to keep expenses down and
remain in his home. Next winter, he
may resort to sleeping in his closet
with a ceramic heater.
"Whatever it
takes," Heath said,
"Ill do it."
The idea that it may
cost thousands of dollars to move
their mobiles has Heath, Schaffran
and other park residents wondering
whether theyll be forced to
walk away from their homes.
"It just plain old
hurts," Schaffran said.
"Ive cried buckets of
tears over it."
Moving costs can be as
high as $10,000, according to David
Kaufman, manufactured home ombudsman
for the Oregon Housing and Community
Services division.
"These are people
who generally dont have that
kind of money," said Kaufman.
"Its a real problem."
Aside from the cost to
move, residents at Crest Imperial
have learned their homes may not be
as mobile as they thought.
County and most city
ordinances relegate mobile homes to
mobile home parks, according to
Joline Thomas, Southern Oregon vice
president for Manufactured Home
Owners of Oregon, a group that
represents park tenants.
But where there are
vacancies, most park owners have put
restrictions on the age of mobile
homes allowed in, Thomas said. Some
parks wont accept homes built
more than five or 10 years ago, she
added.
"The problem with
the industry right now is (owners of
older homes) have no place to
go," Thomas said. "So
theyre left holding the
bag."
When homeowners
cant move or sell their units,
they frequently abandon them,
according to Kaufman. Others try to
dismantle their homes, selling it
piece-by-piece for scrap.
Making a bad situation
worse
No one knows what effect
the closure of Crest Imperial will
have on the Rogue Valleys stock
of affordable housing.
But it cant help
matters, said Betty McRoberts, who
sits on Medfords affordable
housing coalition and oversees
development for the Housing Authority
of Jackson County.
"This just puts
that many more people into the
affordable housing market and we
already know theres not
enough," McRoberts said.
"Its a bad situation, and
this is going to make it worse."
Information on the stock
of affordable housing in Jackson
County is not readily available. But
at the housing authority, which
administers federal programs, more
than 1,500 families are on a waiting
list. It can take up to a year to
place a family once it makes the
list, McRoberts said.
Some local communities
are beginning to search for ways to
preserve and augment their affordable
housing.
In Medford, the City
Council formed a housing coalition to
identify ways to encourage
lower-income families to purchase
homes. The fledgling Ashland
Community Land Trust builds housing
specifically for low-income families.
But while these cities
and other organizations
including Habitat for Humanity,
ACCESS and the Rogue Valley Community
Development Coalition are busy
building new homes, it would take
years to offset the loss of 50-plus
mobile units at Crest Imperial.
Looking for a solution
As frustrated as
Schaffran and her neighbors are by
their situation, they say they really
want communities to begin looking for
ways to assist displaced mobile home
owners.
"This can be a
reality for anyone thats in a
park," said Jeanielynn Russell,
who moved to the Crest Imperial court
a couple years ago.
As land within Medford
and other urban areas becomes more
scarce, owners of mobile home parks
are likely to begin converting their
property to a more profitable use,
industry watchers say.
Russell and her
neighbors point to laws like one in
California, which requires developers
to evaluate the economic impact a
park conversion will have on
residents, as an example for Oregon
to follow.
People might say,
"Thats California,
were in Oregon," said
Russell. "It can be an
irrelevant issue. But they do it in
California because its the
right thing to do. Its the fair
thing to do."
The California law,
adopted in 1981, permits local
jurisdictions to require park owners
and developers to pay relocation
costs for displaced mobile home
owners.
A similar law in Oregon
would likely face opposition from at
least two groups Manufactured
Housing Communities of Oregon and
Oregon Manufactured Housing
Association, which represent
manufactured home builders and park
owners.
Representatives from
those groups say local jurisdictions
should relax zoning rules that
restrict the placement of mobile
homes allowing owners to move
their units outside parks
rather than burden developers or
court owners with paying relocation
costs.
"If the home is in
good condition, why shouldnt
you be able to move it?" asked
Don Miner, executive director for the
Manufactured Housing Association.
"Its an arbitrary line
that has been drawn, and it inflicts
harm on the consumer."
Several bills meant to
protect mobile home buyers were
introduced in the Legislature this
year, but none addressed the effect a
park closure has on residents.
The debate over whether
mobile home dwellers should be
compensated when a park closes is one
that rests for now with court owners
and residents.
Rich Rohde, an Oregon
Action organizer whos worked
with people from Crest Imperial and
two parks in Ashland, said mobile
home park owners should seek out a
"fair and just way" to deal
with displaced residents, whether it
be through relocation assistance,
compensation for the loss of homes or
some other type of aid.
"If everybody sat
down with good intentions, you could
come up with a solution thats
good for everyone."
Reach reporter
Jessica Smith at 776-4481, or e-mail
jsmith@mailtribune.com
|